On 4 September 1957, a report appeared in Britain whose central sentence split opinion for a decade: homosexual behaviour between consenting adults in private should no longer be a criminal offence. The report is named after the committee's chairman, Sir John Wolfenden. It took ten years to become law, and the law applied only to men in England and Wales. The story explains why legal reform is slow and why a partial win is not the end of the story.
Why there was a committee
Under the Criminal Law Amendment Act of 1885, any homosexual act between men was illegal. After the Second World War, arrests and prosecutions rose. By the end of 1954, 1,069 men were in prison in England and Wales for homosexual acts, with an average age of 37. High-profile trials added pressure, among them Lord Montagu of Beaulieu, Michael Pitt-Rivers, John Gielgud and the journalist Peter Wildeblood. The Conservative government set up a committee to look at both homosexual offences and prostitution.
The committee
It had 15 members, eleven men and four women. It first met on 15 September 1954 and sat on 62 days, 32 of them spent hearing witnesses: police, probation officers, psychiatrists, clergy and men whose lives the law had shaped. Clergy were then among the front-runners of reform.
Finding gay men willing to testify was hard. The committee found three: Peter Wildeblood, who had been convicted himself, the museum director Carl Winter and the eye surgeon Patrick Trevor-Roper. To protect them, the latter two appear in the records as the "Doctor" and "Mr White". Wolfenden reportedly called homosexuals "Huntleys" and prostitutes "Palmers", after the biscuit makers, so that the women in the room would not have to hear the words.
What the report recommended
The committee recommended that homosexual behaviour between consenting adults in private should no longer be a criminal offence. Only James Adair dissented. Against the evidence of some medical witnesses, the report held that homosexuality cannot legitimately be regarded as a disease, since it is often the only symptom and is compatible with full mental health.
The proposed age of consent was 21, the age of majority at the time, although for mixed-sex couples it was 16. The report also dealt with street prostitution, and the Street Offences Act 1959 followed. That belongs to the story too: at the same time, street prostitution was policed more strictly.
The reaction
The report set off a public debate. The judge Lord Devlin called it an excellent study but rejected its basic idea that the law should stay out of private immorality. The legal philosopher H. L. A. Hart defended it. In late 1957 the General Assembly of the Church of England voted 155 to 138 to approve the report's principles in general, including on homosexuality.
Harold Macmillan's government still did nothing, for fear of a public backlash. On 29 June 1960 the House of Commons voted 213 to 99 against a motion endorsing the recommendations. Opinion shifted only slowly. Advocacy groups played a part, and so did the 1961 film Victim with Dirk Bogarde, which was about the prosecution of homosexuals and blackmail. After it, approval for repealing the ban went above 50 per cent, according to the account used here.
The road to the statute
Labour won the 1964 general election. On 26 May 1965, Leo Abse narrowly lost a first attempt in the Commons, 178 to 159, a gap small enough to signal a change of mood. On 28 October 1965 the House of Lords passed a bill by Lord Arran, 96 to 31. Humphry Berkeley took it to the Commons but excluded Scotland, so that socially conservative Scottish MPs would not vote against it. The 1966 election interrupted the bill, and Berkeley lost his seat.
The second attempt worked. The Commons passed the bill on 4 July 1967, 99 to 14, and the Lords on 13 July, 111 to 48. It received royal assent on 27 July 1967: the Sexual Offences Act 1967.
What the law allowed and what it did not
The act decriminalised homosexual acts between two consenting men over 21 in private, but only in England and Wales. Scotland followed in 1980, Northern Ireland in 1982. The armed forces and the Merchant Navy were excluded. The age of consent was five years higher than for heterosexual acts. The offences of buggery and gross indecency remained, and men who did not meet the strict conditions could still be prosecuted.
Even the supporters did not sound accepting. Home Secretary Roy Jenkins told Parliament that those who suffer from this "disability" carry a great weight of shame all their lives. After the vote, Lord Arran asked homosexuals to behave quietly and with dignity. The historian Patrick Higgins later criticised the report for failing to understand the homosexual subculture except in negative terms.
What follows from this
The 1967 reform shows how a right often begins as tolerance: private, discreet, with conditions. The road from Wolfenden to the statute took ten years, and after the act, inequalities remained in the age of consent, in the military and in other parts of the country. When you compare legal situations today, it helps to ask not only whether something is legal, but under which conditions.
Status of information: November 2026. The details rely on accounts of the Wolfenden report and the Sexual Offences Act 1967. If you want to cite them, check the primary sources in the UK parliamentary archive.
Frequently asked questions
Sources
- en.wikipedia.org · Wolfenden_report
- en.wikipedia.org · Sexual_Offences_Act_1967